摘要
在行政诉讼司法实践中,诉权滥用个案频发。通过对既有裁判文书的梳理发现,实践中对于涉及滥用诉权案件的审理,呈现出“滥用诉权”和“不正当行使诉权”的裁判进路,囿于法律规范的明确性不足,个案审理中法官对此理解不一,裁判的基本逻辑和观点也有所区分。为增强司法裁判的统一性,应明晰“滥用诉权”和“不正当行使诉权”的关系问题,从“失信”“联合”“惩戒”三个层面出发,规制滥用诉权。
In the judicial practice of administrative litigation,the abuse of the right to sue occurs frequently.However,through sorting out the existing judgment documents,it is found that in practice,the trial of cases involving abuse of the right to sue presents the approach of“abuse of the right to sue”and“improper exercise of the right to sue”.Due to the lack of clarity of legal norms,judges have different understandings of this in case trials,and the basic logic and viewpoints of the judges are also differentiated.Therefore,in order to enhance the unity of judicial judgment,the relationship and standard between“abuse of the right to sue”and“improper exercise of the right to sue”should be clarified,and the abuse of the right to sue should be regulated from the perspectives of“dishonesty”“joint”and“punishment”.
作者
杨林利
Yang Linli(Law School,Sichuan University,Chengdu Sichuan 610207,China)
出处
《河北科技师范学院学报（社会科学版）》
2020年第4期75-81,共7页
Journal of Hebei Normal University of Science & Technology(Social Sciences)
基金
四川大学法学院“研究阐释党的十九届四中全会精神”(sculaw20190303)。
关键词
行政诉讼
滥用诉权
不正行使诉权
失信联合惩戒
administrative litigation
abuse of prosecution
improper exercise of the right to sue
joint punishment for breach of trust
