摘要
文章以与旅游相关的50个检索词在知网(CNKI)中文核心期刊数据库、CSSCI数据库和CSCD数据库中检索出2003-2018年收录的旅游类学术期刊文章,经查重和筛选,最终得到26480篇旅游学术论文作为研究样本。通过分值、h指数与g指数等不同维度对样本涉及的1012种学术刊物、21854名作者和所属的3618家机构进行评价排名,得出的主要结论:(1)旅游类论文广泛发表在包括地理学、经济学、环境科学、体育学、政治学等在内的各类期刊上;(2)虽然头部的前3家院校分别处于东中西部,但从总体看,东部院校比中西部院校在旅游学术成果上表现更突出;(3)师范类院校和地理学科对旅游学术成果的贡献较大;(4)并非综合实力强的院校旅游科研实力更强,许多高职院校对旅游学术贡献也不小;(5)旅游学术成果表现与合作程度存在较强的正相关性,旅游学者之间的广泛合作和跨机构、跨学科的交流融合,有利于旅游学术研究的繁荣和发展;(6)我国旅游学术共同体的代际更替加快,但女性成员占比较低。
The purpose of this study is to review today’s tourism academic research and evaluate periodicals,scholars and institutions engaged in tourism research,based on statistical analysis about tourism articles published in academic journals.50 words related with tourism were adopted to search in three databases,including CNKI,CSSCI and CSCD,for tourism academic journal articles which published during the period 2003-2018.After checking and deleting duplicates and filtering based on a range of conditions,26,480 articles were finally chosen as research sample,which were published in1012 periodicals and written by 21854 authors from 3618 academic institutions,mainly colleges and universities.And then we ranked respectively these periodicals,authors and academic institutions involved in the sample by different dimensions such as"score""h-index"and"g-index".The"score""h-index"and the"g-index"are quantitative tools for evaluating scholars’research performance.The score is calculated as follows:set the score of each article in the sample to 1 and then assign the score to the author according to the number of authors of one article,then score the author’s organization based on the author’s score and finally,the total scores of all authors and institutions are calculated separately.The h-index and g-index methods take into account the citation frequency of the article and the contribution of different authors in each article.From the results of this evaluation ranking and by comparing the results of this evaluation with the results of similar evaluation studies we have done before,we have drawn some conclusions:(1)Tourism discipline is such a comprehensive and cross-disciplinary subject,the tourism academic achievements also exhibits such similar characteristic,as journal articles about tourism were widely published in various journals including geography,economics,environmental science,physical education,political science,etc.There are very few professional journals in tourism,and only the TOURISM TRIBUNE and TOURISM
作者
《旅游学刊》编辑部
张凌云
韩兰
张燕雪
周晓莹
张嗣
无;Editorial Office of Tourism Tribune(Tourism Academic Evaluation Base of China Tourism Research Institute;Tourism College of Beijing Union University;不详)
出处
《旅游学刊》
CSSCI
北大核心
2019年第12期120-136,共17页
Tourism Tribune
关键词
旅游
学术共同体
学术评价
H指数
G指数
tourism
academic community
academic evaluation
h-index
g-index
