摘要
为解决多指标方案的优选问题,进一步丰富方案优选方法类型,提出了优势比较法。从评价指标体系中剔除无用指标,对其余指标进行归一化和加权处理,形成方案集的决策矩阵;根据方案优选的确定性和一致性要求,提出方案相对优势的概念,确立方案相对优势的计算方法,建立方案集的优劣判定矩阵,对不同方案进行优劣排序。水利工程方案优选案例表明:优势比较法计算简便,能够确定可信的最优方案。因此,该方法可与其他评价方法相互佐证,为水利工程方案优选提供更充分的决策依据。
The superiority comparison method(SCM)is presented in this paper,so as to find the best scheme from the scheme set with multi-index and further expand the optimization method library.Initially,the useless indexes are removed from the evaluation index system,and the other indexes are normalized and weighted to form decision matrix of scheme set.According to the demands of determinacy and consistency,the concept of comparative advantage is proposed for the optimal selection.Then,the computing method of comparative advantage is determined and lay the foundation for building the judgment matrix of scheme set,which decides the superiority ranking of each scheme.The optimization of water conservancy project(WCP)schemes shows that SCM is easily utilized and is able to find the credible optimal scheme.Therefore,it could be mutually validated with the other evaluation methods to provide more sufficient decision-making basis for the optimal selection of WCP schemes.
作者
刘赛艳
解阳阳
黄强
王义民
LIU Saiyan;XIE Yangyang;HUANG Qiang;WANG Yimin(State Key Laboratory Base of Eco-hydraulic Engineering in Arid Area,Institute of Water Resources and Hydroelectricity Engineering,Xi'an University of Technology,Xi'an 710048,China;School of Hydrologic Energy and Power Engineering,Research Institute of Modern Rural Water Conservancy,Yangzhou 225009,China)
出处
《人民珠江》
2019年第1期116-120,145,共6页
Pearl River
基金
国家重点研发计划资助(2017YFC0405900)
国家自然科学基金项目(51409210
51647112)
国家留学基金委公派研究生项目(201708610118)
水利部公益性行业科研专项项目(201501058)
陕西省水利科技计划项目(2017slkj-16
2017slkj-27)
关键词
水利工程
方案优选
综合评价
指标归一化
优势比较法
water conservancy project
optimal selection of schemes
comprehensive evaluation
normalization of index
superiority comparison method
