摘要
合法性关切已经成为全球治理和多边主义研究中的一个重要问题。本文认为,一个完整的合法性概念应当同时包括政治学、法学和社会学意义上的合法性概念,这三个方面是相互补充、相辅相成的。就全球环境治理来说,政治学的合法性概念关注其中的民主合法性,使法学和社会学对经验性合法性的强调得到补充,而它对合法律性和政治共同体观念的忽视,分别得到法学和社会学的合法性概念的补充。法学的合法性概念重视合法律性,但往往忽视法律规范背后的价值层次,这又为社会学的合法性概念所补充。当然,即便结合这三个方面也仍面临着一些挑战,主要来自于全球环境治理的政治共同体问题和全球环境治理与其他治理领域的合法性关系问题。
The question of legitimacy has become an important issue in the study of global governance and multilateralism. This paper argues that a comprehensive concept of legitimacy must include the concept of legitimacy of political science, law and sociology. As to global environmental governance, the concept of legitimacy in political science concerns democratic legitimacy in the progress of governance, which complements the emphasis on experimental dimension of legitimacy concept of law and sociology. Meanwhile political science concept of legitimacy lacks concern on the legal legitimacy and political community, which is complemented by the legitimacy concept of law and sociology. The legitimacy concept of law generally concerns about the legal legitimacy and ignores the ethics value behind these law rules which is complemented by the legitimacy concept of sociology. Certainly, the legitimacy concept into which integrates all three dimensions still has some challenges which derive from the issue of political community of global environmental governance and the relationship between environmental governance and other global governance fields.
出处
《教学与研究》
CSSCI
北大核心
2008年第10期45-53,共9页
Teaching and Research
关键词
全球环境治理
政治学合法性
法学合法性
社会学合法性
global environmental governance
legitimacy concept of political science
legitimacy concept of law
legitimacy concept of sociology
