摘要
目前,《中华人民共和国仲裁法》(以下简称《仲裁法》)中尚未确立核阅制度,核阅制度在我国商事仲裁的适用中,也存在着缺乏法律依据,主体不明确,范围不统一,程序不清晰等问题。本文主要研究核阅制度的正当性、现状、缺陷与完善路径。文章论述了核阅制度的基本内容,包括其产生的背景、定义和存在的法理基础,阐述了实行核阅制度过程中的价值平衡,主要探讨核阅制度和尊重当事人意思自治、保障仲裁庭独立性等价值并行存在的可行性,同时分析了核阅制度的现状与缺陷,并针对上述存在的问题提出了相应的完善建议。
At present,the Arbitration Law of the People’s Republic of China has not established a review system.There remains problems including lack of legal basis,unclear subject,inconsistant scope,and unclear procedures in the application of the existing review system in China’s commercial arbitration.This article mainly studies the legitimacy,status quo,defects and improvement paths of the review system.The article discusses the basic content of the review system,including its background,definition and legal basis,expounds the value balance in the implementation of the review system,mainly discusses the feasibility of the parallel existence of the review system and values including respect for the autonomy of the parties,and guarantees the independence of the arbitration tribunal,and then analyzed the current situation and defects of the review system,and put forward corresponding suggestions for improvement in response to the above-mentioned problems.
出处
《商事仲裁与调解》
2021年第2期53-67,共15页
Commercial Arbitration & Mediation
关键词
核阅制度
核阅范围
核阅程序
核阅主体
仲裁法
review system
review scope
review procedure
review subject
arbitration law
