摘要
台湾地区司法机构在涉内地司法裁判中引用国际规范的现象是个复杂而敏感的问题,不可不研究。国际法籍由实定法方式进入台湾地区规范体系的历史过程,是在现实而具体的政治过程中完成,故而这一过程不可避免的充满了政治考量。就基本类型及论证逻辑而言,台湾地区法院在涉内地案件中引用国际规范并不必然产生违反一个中国原则的外部效果。台湾地区法院引用国际规则有一定的背景依据,但同时也存在不当的政治映射影响。内地法院在对台湾地区法院引用国际规则的裁判决定是否予以认可时,需综合全面考察其引用国际规范的路径逻辑、背景依据及政治效果。
The phenomenon of Taiwan judiciary authorities invoking international norms in Mainland-related judicial adjudications is a complex and sensitive issue that must be carefully studied.In terms of basic types and reasoning logic,the invocation of international norms by courts in mainland related cases does not necessarily have the external effect of violating the"One-China"principle.The Taiwan judiciary authorities'application of international norms has a certain background basis,but it also has improper political influence.When the Chinese mainland's courts consider a judgment rendered by a Taiwan court,it is necessary to comprehensively examine the argumentation logic,background basis,and political effects of its application of international norms.
出处
《台湾研究》
CSSCI
北大核心
2023年第1期84-99,共16页
Taiwan Studies
关键词
台湾地区
国际规范
涉内地司法裁判
Taiwan
International Norms
Mainland-related Judicial Adjudication
