摘要
基于2015—2020年著作权侵权司法判决书数据,实证探讨了策略性诉讼者的版权保护绩效。研究发现:策略性诉讼者充分利用制度规则,通过多次、标准化的诉讼策略获取收益,在胜诉率、获赔判决额及法官倾向性等三方面均高于一般当事人;在“黑洞照片”版权事件发生后,尽管法院判决金额有所下降,但其胜诉率仍旧较高,且图片策略性诉讼者的法官倾向性并没有显著降低。策略性诉讼者展现出了专业的维权水平,有效弥补了集体管理机构版权保护不力的空白,能充分发挥策略性诉讼者市场化的权利保护功能,促进我国版权保护水平的整体提高。
Based on the data of judicial judgments on copyright infringement from 2015 to 2020,this paper empirically discusses the copyright protection performance of strategic litigants.The results show that strategic litigants make full use of the system rules to obtain benefits mainly through multiple and standardized litigation strategies,and they are superior to ordinary litigants with regard to winning rate,compensation judgment and judge’s harshness;after the copyright incident of“Photo of the Black Hole”,although the amount of court decision has decreased,the winning rate is still high,and the judge’s harshness of picture strategic litigants has not decreased significantly.Strategic litigants show their professional level of rights protection,which effectively makes up for the lack of effective copyright protection of collective management institutions.After promoting the advantages and eliminating the disadvantages,strategic litigants can give full play to the market-oriented rights protection function and promote the overall improvement of copyright protection in China.
作者
魏建
田燕梅
WEI Jian;TIAN Yan-mei(Editorial Department,Journal of Shandong University(Philosophy and Social Sciences),Jinan 250100;School of Economics and Trade,Shandong Management University,Jinan 250357,China)
出处
《广东财经大学学报》
CSSCI
北大核心
2022年第2期88-99,共12页
Journal of Guangdong University of Finance & Economics
基金
国家社会科学基金一般项目(19BJY013)
山东大学人文社会科学重大研究项目(18RWZD15)。
关键词
版权蟑螂
策略性诉讼
法院判决
版权保护
著作权侵权
版权
法经济学
copyright troll
strategic litigation
court decisions
copyright protection
copyright infringement
copyright
Law and Economics
