摘要
在《民法典婚姻家庭编(草案)》的修订过程中,利益与伦理之间的选择困境日益凸显,其问题的核心在于婚姻家庭立法所秉持的利益分配理念。这种理念的意义脉络表现为“利益评价”“利益选择”与“非利益漠视”,其文化进路可以概括为“定分止争”的思维惯性与近代“集团生活”方式的传入。以社会系统论为理路,立法实践所表现出的问题实质是利益分配理念在立法过程中造成的“进化”困境,其原因在于知识系统上被动的“自我封闭”,以及面对其他选择机制时的“排他性”。对其的纾解可以从三个方面着手,即在立法文本中表达“利益”的多元价值涵摄、以法逻辑学原理检视立法文本的逻辑有效性,以及对传统立法经验的借鉴。
In the process of revising the Civil Code Marriage and Family Code(Draft),the dilemma of choice between interests and ethics has become increasingly prominent.The core of the problem lies in the idea of distribution of interests held by the marriage and family legislation.The significance of this idea is embodied in interest evaluation,interest choice and non interest indifference.Its cultural approach can be summarized as the thinking inertia of dividing and stopping disputes and the introduction of modern group life.Based on the theory of social system,the essence of the problem in legislative practice is the dilemma of evolution caused by the idea of interests distribution in the process of legislation.The reason lies in the passive self closure in the knowledge system and the exclusiveness in the face of other selection mechanisms.The relief can be carried out from three aspects:to express the multiple value implications of interests in the legislative text,to examine the logical validity of the legislative text with the principle of logic of law,and to learn from the traditional legislative experience.
作者
戴巍巍
李拥军
DAI Wei-wei;LI Yong-jun(School of Law, Jilin University, Changchun Jilin 130000, China)
出处
《内蒙古社会科学》
CSSCI
北大核心
2020年第3期134-140,共7页
Inner Mongolia Social Sciences
基金
教育部人文社会科学重点研究基地重大项目“文化传统在法治中国建设中的创造性转化研究”(编号:17JJD820004)。
关键词
社会系统理论
婚姻家庭编
法的进化
兼容性
意义同一化
Social System Theory
Marriage and Family Code
Evolution of Law
Compatibility
Meaning Assimilation
