摘要
社会主义核心价值观对指导性案例的形成具有指引作用。指导性案例中对核心价值观之具体内容的直接引用或间接体现,对案例形成前期的司法个案裁判具有指导意义。核心价值观参与司法适用,应具体化为一种司法价值观,并明确其适用的具体边界,以减少适用的主观性、伦理性、非规范性与不确定性。根据司法价值观的一般内容要求,应对核心价值观的内容予以选择,并兼顾核心价值观的道德引领与法理论证,注重核心价值观各内容要素之间的关联性。核心价值观对于形成后的指导性案例具有分类作用,应注意形成核心价值观不同具体内容方面的案例群,并明确指导性案例形成的主要目的。
The socialist core values have a guiding role in the formation of the guiding case. The direct reference or indirect expression of the core values in the guiding case has guiding significance for the judicial case judgment in the early stage of the case formation. The inclusion of core values in judicial application should be embodied as a judicial value and the specific boundaries of its application should be clarified to reduce the subjectivity, ethics, non-normativeness and uncertainty of application. According to the general content requirements of judicial values, we should choose the content of core values, and take into account the moral leadership of the core values and the theoretical proof of the law, paying attention to the relevance of each content element. The core values have a classification effect on the formed guiding cases. Attention should be paid to the formation of case groups in different values and the main purpose of guiding the formation of the guiding cases.
作者
刘艳红
刘浩
LIU Yanhong;LIU Hao(Southeast University Law School)
出处
《法学家》
CSSCI
北大核心
2020年第1期90-104,193,194,共17页
The Jurist
基金
国家重点研发计划“面向诉讼全流程的一体化便民服务技术及装备研究”(2018YFC0830200)
国家社科基金重大招标课题“大数据与审判体系和审判能力现代化研究”(17ZDA131)的阶段性成果
江苏高校“青蓝工程”的资助
