摘要
提供侵入、非法控制计算机信息系统的程序、工具罪和帮助信息网络犯 罪活动罪项下公开的一审判决书显示,实践中对下游犯罪、“明知”的把握缺乏明 确标准,并且对帮助行为本身较为关注。网络空间中犯罪帮助行为应依其危害性和 独立性进行分类,确立不同的入罪标准。对下游犯罪实行行为的促进作用程度与网 络帮助行为的危害性、独立性直接相关,据此可将网络帮助行为分为三类:对下游 犯罪实行行为有极大促进作用类;对下游犯罪实行行为有部分促进作用类;帮助下 游犯罪前后期类。第一类对应提供专门用于侵入、非法控制计算机信息系统的程 序、工具犯罪,第二类对应明知他人实施侵入、非法控制计算机信息系统的违法犯 罪行为而为其提供程序、工具犯罪,第三类对应帮助信息网络犯罪活动罪。对于第 一类,可以独立评价帮助行为的危害性;对于第二类、第三类,仍要求对帮助下游 犯罪应具备 “明知”要素以及应查实下游犯罪的不法性。
Analysis of written judgments indicates that,in judicial practice relating to cybercrime aiding activities,attention has been focused on the chaotic standards on the aided crimes and the mem reu of the act of aiding the crime,as well as the actus reus of the aiders.Acts of providing aid for cybercrimes can he categorized according to such criteria as their harmfulness and independency,and convicted according to corresponding standards.The completion degree of the actus reus of the aided cybercrimes is directly related to the harmfulness and independency of the aiding activities.According to the completion degree,acts of providing aid for cybercrimes can he categorized into three types;aiding substantial part of the actus reus of cybercrimes;aiding some part of the actus reus;and aiding in the preparation for the crime or at the late stage of the crime.The first type corresponds to the act of providing programs or tools for the commission of the crime of hacking into or illegally controlling a computer information system.The second type corresponds to the act of knowingly providing programs or tools to a person who is about to commit the crime of hacking into or illegally controlling a computer information system.The third type corresponds to the act of providing aid for the commission of information network crime.The above relations of correspondence are supported by textual interpretation.legislative and judicial intentions,characteristics of cyber programs,and the harmfulness of the aiding activities.The first type can independently evaluate the harmfulness of the crime,while the second and the third types require the ascertainment of the act of knowingly aiding a crime and the illegality of the aided crimes.The act of providing aid for large number of activities that have only small harms individually or cannot he convicted as a crime can he evaluated as the second or the third type.
出处
《法学研究》
CSSCI
北大核心
2019年第5期138-156,共19页
Chinese Journal of Law
基金
“国家重点研究计划(2018YFC0830905)”资助
关键词
网络帮助行为
提供侵入、非法控制计算机信息系统的程序、工具罪
帮
助信息网络犯罪活动罪
明知
providing aid for the commission of cybercrimes
providing programs or tools for the commission of the crime of hacking into or illegally controlling a computer information system
providing aid for commission of information network crime
mens reu
