摘要
在现行法律框架下,检委会定位为检察机关业务决策机构,这种职能定位在实践中面临着议案职能和议事职能履行错位、议案职能的行政化对诉讼规则的抵牾、决策程序一元化与职能二元化的冲突等现实困境。关于检委会职能定位改革,主要有议案职能适度司法化、向办案组织转型、向咨询指导组织转型等三种代表性观点。检委会制度已内化成为稳定的检察制度文化,检委会制度改革不能彻底颠覆其业务决策机构的职能定位。在司法责任制改革的背景下,检委会可以向不讨论案件事实的业务决策机构转型,逐步形成议事为主、议案为辅的检委会职能定位新格局。
Under the current legal framework,the procuratorial committee is regarded as the business decision-making body within the procuratorial organ. In practice,the procuratorial committee has stepped into dilemma,following several problems: dislocation of function of case decision and event decision; conflict between the administration of case decision and litigation principle; conflict between single decision procedure and dual function. There are three representative views on the reform of procuratorial committee: moderate judicialization of the function of case decision;transition to the case handling organization; or transition to consulting organization. As a stable culture of procuratorial system,the reform of the procuratorial committee cannot completely subvert the business decision-making body. In the context of the reform of judicial responsibility system,the procuratorial committee may turn to the business decision-making body which does not discuss the facts of the case.
出处
《国家检察官学院学报》
CSSCI
北大核心
2018年第1期61-75,共15页
Journal of National Prosecutors College
