摘要
对数字技术发展所带来法律问题的研究推动数字法学作为学术命题被提出。虽然数字法学发展迅速,已成为学界热门研究领域,但关于数字法学立论基础等理论问题的研究仍较为薄弱。一方面,数字法学缺乏明确的问题领域,所研究的问题本质上是技术问题,可以通过对现有法学理论体系的完善获得解释;另一方面,数字法学缺少充分的理论建构,既没有突破传统权力理论框架,也没有提出技术超越理论。因此,数字法学在问题领域和理论建构两方面均无法被证成。与其说数字法学是一种法学研究新范式,不如承认数字法学本质上是对技术应用场景的模糊概括。数字社会只是观察社会的众多视角之一,数字社会的到来并不必然意味着法学研究转向了数字法学。在法学理论上,数字法学并不是一个真实的学术命题。
Although digital law has developed rapidly and has become a popular research field in the academic community,research on theoretical issues such as the foundation of digital law is still relatively weak.On the one hand,digital law lacks clear problem areas,and the problems studied are essentially technical issues that can be explained by improving the existing legal theoretical system;on the other hand,digital law lacks sufficient theoretical construction and neither breaks through the tradition.The theoretical framework of power does not propose a theory of technological transcendence.Therefore,digital jurisprudence cannot be justified both in terms of problem areas and theoretical construction.Rather than saying that digital law is a new paradigm of legal research,it is better to admit that digital law is essentially a vague summary of technology application scenarios.In legal theory,digital law is not a real academic proposition.
作者
宋维志
SONG Weizhi(Koguan School of Law,Shanghai Jiao Tong University,Shanghai 200030,China;School of Law,Nanchang University,Nanchang 330031,China)
出处
《现代法学》
北大核心
2024年第1期78-91,共14页
Modern Law Science
基金
国家社科基金重点项目“法治建设视野下的中央和地方关系实证研究”(23AFX002)。
关键词
数字法学
数字社会
数字技术
法学理论
新法学
digital law
digital society
digital technology
jurisprudence
new science of law
