摘要
将宽严相济政策定位为基本刑事政策,彰显了其在刑事法领域的价值和影响,却不可避免地遮掩了其在其他法领域取得的重要甚至是突破性的发展。无论是宽严相济政策自身的价值,还是其在衔接协调不同性质惩治措施之间的作用,都决定了宽严相济政策不应偏居一隅仅作为一项基本刑事政策,而应进阶为刑事处罚、行政处罚、惩罚性赔偿以及政务处分和党纪处分等全部国家惩治制定和实施的基本政策。作为国家基本惩治政策的宽严相济政策,应妥善处理其与法规范之间的关系,宜以基本原则的形式出现在国家惩治规范之中。
Positioning the policy of tempering justice with mercy as a basic criminal policy highlights its value and influence in the field of criminal law,but inevitably masks its importance and even breakthrough development in other fields of law.Whether based on the value of the policy of tempering justice with mercy itself or its role in connecting and coordinating punishment measures of different natures,it determines that the policy of tempering justice with mercy should not be regarded as a basic criminal policy,but should be advanced into the basic policies formulated and implemented by all punishments,such as criminal punishment,administrative punishment,punitive compensation,administrative punishment and Party discipline punishment.As the national basic punishment policy,the policy of tempering justice with mercy should properly deal with the relationship between it and legal norms,and should appear in the national punishment norms in the form of basic principles.
作者
邱帅萍
QIU Shuaiping(Hunan University of Science and Technology,Xiangtan Hunan 411201,China)
出处
《法学论坛》
CSSCI
北大核心
2022年第5期107-120,共14页
Legal Forum
基金
国家社科基金项目《基于统一法秩序的预防性惩罚机制构建研究》(21CFX070)阶段性研究成果。
关键词
宽严相济
刑事政策
惩治政策
基本原则
temper justice with mercy
criminal policy
punishment policy
basic principle
