摘要
人格尊严的至上性无法成为提高收买被拐卖妇女罪法定刑的规范依据,本罪保护的法益是被拐卖妇女的人身安全,应当将其理解为危险犯;对共同对向犯采取归纳推理的方法演绎出应当提高法定刑的结论缺乏说服力;体系评价收买被拐卖妇女罪,其属于重罪范畴,无需再提高法定刑。本罪犯罪人并无矫正之必要,提高其刑罚不仅难以实现报应正义,其所产生的威吓效果也较为有限。在维持本罪法定刑的前提下,综合评价犯罪人罪行、构建非法拘禁、强奸行为的刑事推定规则,并且严格适用法律才是当下破除收买被拐卖妇女案件司法困境的应对之道。
The supremacy of human dignity cannot be the normative basis for improving the statutory sentence for the crime of buying and selling abducted women.The legal interest protected by this crime is the personal safety of abducted and trafficked women,which should be understood as dangerous criminals;the conclusion that the legal penalty should be increased is not convincing by the method;the system evaluates the crime of buying abducted and trafficked women,which belongs to the category of serious crimes,and there is no need to increase the legal penalty.There is no need for correction for the offender of this crime,and raising his penalty is not only difficult to achieve justice,but also has limited intimidating effect.Under the premise of maintaining the statutory sentence for this crime,comprehensively evaluating the crime of the offender,constructing criminal presumption rules for illegal detention and rape,and strictly applying the law are the solutions to the current judicial dilemma in the case of buying abducted and trafficked women.
作者
郑博文
ZHENG Bo-wen(Law School,Southwest University of Science and Technology,Mianyang Sichuan 621000,China)
出处
《山东青年政治学院学报》
2022年第4期58-67,共10页
Journal of Shandong Youth University of Political Science
关键词
收买被拐卖的妇女罪
法定刑
刑法教义学
刑罚根据
司法应对
the crime of buying abducted and trafficked women
statutory sentence
criminal law dogmatics
basis for punishment
judicial response
