摘要
新近立法对污染环境罪内容的改动集中体现了伦理层面价值观的演变历程、犯罪论层面结果无价值和行为无价值的动态调整,以及刑罚论层面报应主义与预防主义的分配理念。三个层面存在的三组二律背反又存在一定的逻辑关联与发展联系,均可归结为刑法积极立法趋势下存在的法益保护早期化与刑法谦抑性的矛盾问题。我国环境犯罪治理的发展道路应当坚守刑罚法规的适正性,以罚则内容明确、处罚范围适中、罪行轻重均衡为具体标准,在刑罚配置上贯彻落实比例原则、细化罚金刑适用幅度甚至扩展保安处分措施。
The changes in the content of the crime of environmental pollution in recent legislation embodies the evolution of values at the ethical level,the dynamic adjustment of worthless results and worthless behaviors at the level of crime theory,and the distribution ideas of retribution and precaution at the level of penalty theory.There are three groups of antinomy at three levels,and there are certain logical connections and development connections,which can all be attributed to the contradiction between the early protection of legal interests and the modesty of criminal law under the positive legislative trend of criminal law.The development path of environmental crime governance in China should adhere to the appropriateness of penalty laws and regulations,take clear penalty content,moderate penalty scope and balanced severity of crimes as specific standards,implement the principle of proportionality in penalty allocation,refine the application range of fine penalty and even expand security measures.
作者
刘德法
白雅楠
Liu Defa;Bai Yanan(Law School,Zhengzhou University,Zhengzhou,Henan 450001)
出处
《河南财经政法大学学报》
CSSCI
2022年第2期44-51,共8页
Journal of Henan University of Economics and Law
关键词
环境刑法
环境犯罪
刑罚观念
法规适正
environmental criminal law
environmental crime
concept of penalty
appropriateness of laws and regulations
