摘要
非共识项目在促进科技创新方面的作用越来越突出,其评审、评价问题也变得更加重要。文章分析了非共识产生原因,介绍了非共识项目识别和度量方法;之后提出通过评议项目累计数、评议结果命中率和成功率来对同行评议专家进行评价,遴选出非共识项目评审专家;最后结合非共识项目自身特点,利用定性和定量方法建立了非共识项目评价指标体系,探讨了APF组合分析方法运用于非共识项目评价的可能性和具体步骤,以促进非共识项目发展。
Non-consensus projects play an increasingly important role in promoting scientific and technological innovation.This paper analyzes the causes of non consensus,introduces the methods of identifying and measuring non-consensus project. Then it is proposed that peer review expert evaluation should be carried out by reviewing item cumulative count,dispersion rate,hit probability and success rate.The evaluation index system is established based on the characteristics of non-consensus projects.At last,this paper discusses the possibility and concrete steps of applying APF combinatorial analysis method to non-consensus project evaluation by combining complex qualitative and quantitative indicators.
作者
西桂权
王冠宇
Xi Guiquan;Wang Guanyu(Beijing institute of science and technology information,Beijing,100048)
出处
《科技智囊》
2020年第5期35-39,共5页
Think Tank of Science & Technology
基金
北京市科学技术研究院改革与发展培育项目(PY2020ZK17)的阶段性成果之一。
关键词
非共识项目
非共识度
同行评议
APF评价方法
Non-consensus project
Non-consensus degree
Peer review
APF evaluation method
