摘要
郭静云女士所著《夏商周:从神话到史实》一书出版以来,在学界引发热议。该书视野宏阔,新见迭出,但在文献、考古、古文字的史料运用方面不无可商之处。郭著虽时刻在强调多元,但实则在强化其"江汉中心说"。江汉地区与其他区域之间的互动关系,尚有待进一步探讨。郭著最值得注意的,是其将中国文明的早期发展进程置诸欧亚大陆的宏观视野中予以考察。唯有从欧亚大陆的视野中予以观照,才能更清晰地看出中国古代文明的演进历程。由郭著引发的争议,亦可为古史重建路径的反思提供新的契机。
Since the publication of Xia,Shang and Zhou Dynasties:From Myth to History written by Pro.Olga Gorodetskaya,there has been a controversy between different scholars.The book has a broad field of vision and new ideas,but there are still some deficiencies in using materials of transmitted texts,archaeological discoveries and excavated texts.Although this book recognized that the formation process of Chinese civilization is pluralistic,it indeed argued the Jianghan central theory.The relationship between Jianghan area and Central Plains area needs further research.The most remarkable work of this book is that it put the early development of Chinese civilization into the Eurasian perspective.Only from the Eurasian perspective can we see the evolution of Chinese civilization more clearly.The controversy caused by this book also provides a new opportunity for rethinking of the reconstruction path of ancient Chinese history.
作者
陈民镇
CHEN Min-zhen(Institute of Chinese Culture,Beijing Language and Culture University,Beijing 100083,China)
出处
《齐鲁学刊》
CSSCI
北大核心
2020年第1期52-62,共11页
Qilu Journal
基金
浙江省哲学社会科学规划重点项目“文明的对话:世界古代文明视野中的良渚文明”(19WH50060ZD-3Z)。
关键词
古史重建
郭静云
江汉中心说
欧亚视野
reconstruction of ancient Chinese history
Olga Gorodetskaya
Jianghan central theory
Eurasian perspective
