摘要
[目的/意义]对国内外最新期刊评价方法进行梳理,了解研究进展,有助于学界理清期刊评价发展的方向和趋势,为完善期刊评价与管理实践、推动期刊评价方法革新提供科学依据。[方法/过程]以国外文献为重点,兼顾近几年国内的最新研究,根据一定的筛选标准对60篇与学术期刊评价方法相关的优质文献进行了内容分析,按预设的主题对相关内容全面梳理。[结果/结论]将学术期刊评价方法分为基于感知的期刊评价、基于引文的期刊评价、混合评价和元评价四类,发现了目前学术期刊评价方法研究在方法运用、期刊选择、数据来源、数据整合、效度保证、结果呈现等六个方面存在的一些特征,对现有研究存在的问题和未来发展趋势进行了讨论。
[Purpose/Significance]Combing the latest methods of journal evaluation and understanding the progress of research will help the academic circles to clarify the direction and trend of journal evaluation development,and provide a scientific basis for improving journal evaluation and management practice and promoting innovation of journal evaluation methods.[Method/Process]Focusing on foreign literatures,taking into account the latest research in China in recent years,based on certain screening criteria,60 core articles related to academic journal evaluation methods are analyzed,and related content is combed based on preset themes.Comprehensively sorted out.[Results/Conclusions]The academic journal evaluation methods are divided into four categories:perception-based journal evaluation,citation-based journal evaluation,mixed evaluation and meta-evaluation.The research reveals some characteristics of the current academic journal evaluation methods researches in the 6 aspects of method application,journal selection,data source,data integration,validity guarantee and result presentation,and discusses the existing research problems and future development trends.
作者
胡绍君
郑彦宁
成颖
Hu Shaojun;Zheng Yanning;Cheng Ying(School of Information Management,Nanjing University,Nanjing 210023;Northeast Petroleum University Library,Daqing 163318;Institute of Scientific and Technical Information of China,Beijing 100038)
出处
《情报杂志》
CSSCI
北大核心
2020年第2期169-175,共7页
Journal of Intelligence
关键词
期刊评价方法
基于感知的期刊评价
基于引文的期刊评价
混合评价
元评价
journal evaluation method
perception-based journal evaluation
citation-based journal evaluation
mixed journal evaluation
meta-evaluation
