摘要
刑法学与民法学是看似相互独立、泾渭分明的两种学科,但在纷繁复杂的司法实践中,刑事法律关系和民事法律关系交织在同一案件中的现象却多如牛毛,其中所涉及的案件性质认定、刑民责任划分、程序适用等问题也一直是困扰着各级司法机关的疑难问题。当前司法实践中主要有先刑后民、刑民并行、先民后刑三种刑民交叉案件的审理模式,三种模式可以说是互有优劣并有其特定的适用范围。本文通过对三种审理模式进行利弊分析,提出了依据刑民交叉案件类型灵活选择审理模式的观点。
Punishment law into and seemingly are independent of each other,the two distinct disciplines,but in the complicated judicial practice,criminal law and civil legal relations interweave in the same phenomena are a dime a dozen,in the case of the cases involved nature determination,punishment and responsibility division,application also has been plagued by problems such as the problems of judicial organs at all levels.The current judicial practice mainly include punishment queen people,tortured people first in parallel,the ancients punishment three people after cross processing pattern of case,three models can be said to be the advantages and disadvantages with each other and have their specific scope.Through the analysis of the advantages and disadvantages of the three modes of treatment,this paper puts forward the view that the mode of treatment should be chosen flexibly according to the types of cross-cases.
作者
李贵扬
曹萌萌
LI Gui-yang;CAO Meng-meng(Law School,Henan Normal University,Xinxiang 453000,China)
出处
《南阳理工学院学报》
2018年第5期23-27,共5页
Journal of Nanyang Institute of Technology
关键词
刑民交叉
审理模式
公平与效率
法秩序统一性
the cross of criminal and civil,trial mode,fairness and efficiency,the unity of law order
