摘要
为了自查编辑的退稿失误率,提高编辑初审退稿的准确率,兼顾编辑工作效率和期刊质量,调查了《中国水稻科学》2010—2014年间的769篇退稿在他刊的发表情况。截至2017年5月,235篇未发表,534篇退稿在125种刊物上发表,其中92篇退稿发表在影响因子高于1.0的期刊。17篇退稿出现一稿两刊。在刊出的534篇文章中,134篇被引频次为0,102篇被引频次为1,181篇被引频次为2~5,被引频次在10以上的仅有65篇。笔者认为,通过提高编辑的学术素养,增进对专业研究领域的把握,可以减少稿件误判率,做到精准退稿,同时,编辑应掌握沟通技巧,培养亲和力,保证期刊的可持续发展。
To self-examine editors ＇rate of mistaken rejection of manuscripts,improve the accuracy of editors＇ initial rejection and take into account the efficiency of editing and the quality of journals,we sampled 769 manuscripts which were rejected by Chinese Journal of Rice Science during 2010 to 2014,and tracked whether these manuscripts were published in other journals by searching in the full-text database of CNKI in May 2017. Our results showed that 235 manuscripts were unpublished,and 534 manuscripts were published in 125 scientific journals, among which,92 were published in the journals with impact factors higher than 1. 0. For the 534 manuscripts,the citation frequency of 134,102,181 ones were 0,1,and 2-5,respectively,only 65 ones were above 10. We could reduce mis-rejection rate by improving the academic quality of editors,and acquiring well-knit professional knowledge. Besides,editors should master communication skills,cultivate their affinity,and ensure the sustainable development of journals.
作者
职桂叶
阮刘青
ZHI Guiye;RUAN Liuqing(Editorial Department of Chinese Journal of Rice Science,China National Rice Research Institute,311401,Hangzhou,China)
出处
《编辑学报》
CSSCI
北大核心
2018年第4期379-382,共4页
Acta Editologica
关键词
退稿
学术论文
学术期刊
被引频次
rejected manuscripts
scientific paper
scientificjournal
citation frequency
