摘要
以不同的"国情论"为依据,中国的民事司法改革在"左派"的中国模式论与"右派"的西方模式论之间摇摆不定。民事审判结构理论通过提出与社会结构转型和谐共变的法律进化机制,能够以动态、多元的国情论作为基础而可以整合并超越中国模式论与西方模式论,并在两者之间形成动态的反思性监控,从而迈向了民事司法改革的第三条道路,并最终可能导向正式程序占主要地位、马锡五审判方式占次要地位的民事司法的第三种模式。
Base on the different ＂theories of the National Conditions＂,our civil justice reforms oscillating between the left wing of ＂the Chinese Model＂and the right wing of ＂the Western Model＂. The Civil Trial Structure Theory put forward a legal evolutionary mechanism making an harmonious covariation with the transformation of social struction,which could base on the dynamic and multiple ＂theories of the National Conditions＂ to integrate and transcend the ＂China Model ＂ and the ＂Western Model＂,and forming a dynamic reflective monitoring between the two models. It is the Third Way of civil justice reforms,which could orient to the third pattern of civil justice,which the procedural formalism playing a major role and Ma xiwu trial model playing a minor role.
作者
徐昀
XU Yun(College of Humanities and Law, Yanshan University, Qinhuangdao 066004 Chin)
出处
《河北法学》
CSSCI
北大核心
2017年第5期2-13,共12页
Hebei Law Science
基金
河北社科基金<后十八大时代的民事诉讼模式演进研究>(HB15FX006)的阶段性成果
燕山大学青年基金<新司法改革运动视角下法院调解制度研究>(14SKA00 7)的阶段性成果
