摘要
一般生效判决和指导性案例在约束力方面实有判决的效力与案例的效力之分。指导性案例的编撰应以有益于实现案例的效力为目标,其具体过程表现出值得关注的方法论特征。指导性案例的编撰既要立足于既有生效判决文书,运用案件事实的剪裁和判决结果的采编方法实现对案件文本的剪辑,同时又要通过判决理由的提取和裁判要点的著作完成对案例裁判要旨的著述。
The general effective judgments and the guiding cases actually have the effectiveness of the judgment and the effectiveness of the cases with the binding force. Compilation of guiding case should take realizing the effectiveness of case helpfully as the target, and its concrete process shows the noteworthy characteristics in the methodology. On the one hand, the compilation of guiding cases needs to be based on the existing effective judgment documents, and use the method of case facts clipping and judicial decisions collecting to realize the case text edition. On the other hand, it needs to complete the composition of judicial gist in the case by extrac- ting judgment reasons and writing judgment key points.
出处
《河南财经政法大学学报》
2015年第2期46-56,共11页
Journal of Henan University of Economics and Law
基金
司法部2013年国家法治与法学理论研究项目"指导性案例的编著方法研究"的阶段性成果(项目编号:13SFB5006)
