摘要
张法教授认为在中国古代要成为"像模像样"的人就一定要写诗,这种说法言不及义、隔靴搔痒,一方面置中国诗歌悠久的"诗言志"、"诗缘情"传统于不顾;另一方面将先民出人头地的方式绝对化了。他还断言科举考试最重要的内容是诗歌,这种笼统的说法与历史严重不符。诗歌在中国传统文化中的确占有十分重要的位置,但张教授在论证过程中除了犯一些常识性的舛误之外,很多地方还存在逻辑的硬伤。
Professor Zhang Fa believes that to become somebody in ancient China,people have towrite poetry. On the one hand,this view ignores the long tradition of'Poetry Expressing Ideals'and'Poetry Root in Feeling'in Chinese poetry history,which seems ineffective and frivolous,and on the other hand it makes absolute the way to success of the ancients. He also asserts that the poetry is the most important elements of Imperial Examination. This general statement is seriously inconsistent with the history. In traditional Chinese culture,poetry indeed occupies a very important position.However,in addition to some mistakes of common sense,there are still many flawed logics in the demonstration process of Professor Zhang.
出处
《学术界》
CSSCI
北大核心
2014年第5期114-118,310-311,共5页
Academics
关键词
中国传统文化
诗歌
常识
逻辑
Chinese traditional culture
poetry
common sense
logic
