摘要
张功耀教授的成名作"告别中医中药"谬误百出:对基础知识包括基本原理掌握不够准确;所持观点极其偏颇,且缺乏充分的论证;研究方法不符合学术规范,任意选取有利论据;从概念、命题、推理到逻辑规律都存在谬误;在行文中,字词句章都存在疏误。张功耀教授的学术素养不足是导致如此多谬误的主要原因。学界缺乏正常的学术批评,科研管理机构、教育管理机构对学术不端整治不力是张功耀式学术不端得以存续的社会原因。
It is full of fallacies in the paper ＂Farewell to Traditional Chinese Medicine and Remedies＂ by Zhang Gongyao： the basic knowledge including basic principles is not accurate enough; the views are extremely biased and short of sufficient demonstration; the research methods do not meet the academic standard, and the selected argument is arbitrary; and there are errors in concepts, propositions, logical reasoning and the text itself. The deficiency of Zhang Gongyao＇ s academic accomplishment may be the main cause of so many fallacies. And the lack of normal academic criticism in the academic circles, and the inefficiency of the educational and scientific research administrative institutions in punishment of the academic misconducts, are all the social reasons for the academic misconducts as Zhang Gongyao＇ s.
出处
《北京科技大学学报（社会科学版）》
2013年第4期54-68,共15页
Journal of University of Science and Technology Beijing(Social Sciences Edition)
关键词
张功耀
告别中医中药
谬误
学术不端
Zhang Gongyao
Farewell to Traditional Chinese Medicine and Remedies
fallacy
the academic misconduct
