摘要
侵权责任法不应规定"新闻侵权"或"媒体侵权"。依文义分析看,支持"新闻(媒体)侵权"者,既未能明确协调好"新闻(媒体)侵权"与侵害名誉权、侵害隐私权等侵权行为之间的关系,又未能解决好"新闻(媒体)侵权"的特殊性问题;从比较法上看,无论是大陆法系的老法典、新法典,还是比较注重实用和实践经验的美国法,都没有承认"新闻(媒体)侵权";我国的立法与司法解释也从未规定过"新闻(媒体)侵权"。"新闻(媒体)侵权"之所以不被世界各国所采纳,根本原因在于,它与近现代民法的基本技术方法背道而驰。
Whether or not to stipulate ＂tort by news report＂ or ＂ tort by media＂, is a controversial issue in the process of tort liability law legislation. Those who propose to stipulate can not cooperate well the relation between ＂tort by media＂ and damage to name and privacy and do not solve the particularity of ＂ tort by media＂; All Foreign legislations include classical codes of civil law system and the American law do not recognize so - called ＂tort by media＂ ; China＇ s legislation and judicial interpretations do not mention this problem. So the author suggests that this issue should not be included in tort liability law.
出处
《中国法学》
CSSCI
北大核心
2008年第6期183-189,共7页
China Legal Science
