摘要
公民的住宅权受到宪法保护,政府是否可以通过行政检查来限制这种宪法权利,这就是本文要讨论的关键问题。行政检查与刑事搜查是不同的。相对于刑事搜查而言,行政检查的形式要件是比较简单的。既然行政检查和刑事搜查可能都会涉及被嫌疑人的住所,既然用检查证和搜查证都可以进入被嫌疑人的住所,那么两者就很容易被模糊界限而出现滥用的情况。如果行政检查不需要搜查证,那么警察是否还会刻意去获得搜查证?因此,降低行政检查的标准,就会出现以行政检查为虚、以刑事搜查为实的严重恶果。尤其当警察兼具行政执法和刑事侦查任务时,这种情况更难以避免。
ection is different from a search. Furthermore, the requirements for an administrative inspection are simpler than that of a search. Since both an administrative inspection and a search could be applied to a suspect＇ s home, it is important to draw a line between them. If an administrative inspection does not need a search warrant, whether polices would intend to obtain it in practice？ Therefore, one possible consequence is that a real search would be conducted in the name of an administrative inspection. This serious consequence must be avoided.
出处
《时代法学》
2007年第4期58-64,共7页
Presentday Law Science
关键词
住宅权
行政检查
刑事搜查
搜查证
right to home
administrative inspection
search
search warrant
