摘要
抄本《明史列传》的撰者被定为徐乾学是错误的。该书卷首韩方卓的跋文失误颇多,不足以证明此书为徐乾学所撰。有关徐乾学的传记资料和明史纂修的史料亦可印证徐乾学未曾撰写过《明史列传》。将该书与万斯同的《明史》和王鸿绪的《明史稿》比较后,确认此书系后人将上述两书的诸臣传中各抄录一部分组合后,另题名为《明史列传》。
It is mistaken to define the writer of the manuscript entitled Biographies of the History of the Ming Dynasty. There are a lot of mistakes in the epilogue by Hart Fangzhuo in volume header of the book. Hence there is not enough evidence to prove that this book was written by Xu Qianxue.The biographical materials and the historical materials in the compilation of the history of the Ming Dynasty could confirm that Xu Qianxue had never written such a book as Biographies of the History of the Ming Dynasty. After comparison with the History of the Ming Dynasty and the Manuscript of the History of the Ming Dynasty, it can be confirmed that this book had been compiled through the combination of the biographies of different ministers in the two books and became known as Biographies of the History of the Ming Dynasty.
出处
《咸阳师范学院学报》
2007年第3期50-54,共5页
Journal of Xianyang Normal University
关键词
抄本《明史列传》
撰者
徐乾学
考辨
the manuscript entitled Biographies of the History of the Ming Dynasty
writer
Xu Qianxue
differentiation
