摘要
刑事案件社会结构对司法场域运作过程存在影响,这种社会异质性因素对司法裁判的作用与罪刑法定原则的要求存在紧张关系。以罪刑法定原则是不可撼动的"金律"而彻底否认案件社会结构的作法,无异于画地为牢。认可罪刑法定原则的局限性,建构案件社会结构对于罪刑法定原则边界界定作用的方法,较为合理。超越价值绝对主义的认识论,是罪刑法定原则从"口号"走向"制度",从而真正司法化的基础。该方法在欧洲人权法院对于罪刑法定原则的再认识中可以找到依据。
The social structure of a criminal case has essential effects on the process of the criminal justice,but these effects may conflict with the principle of legality.The ideas which deny the social structure are not reasonable,which consider the legality principle as the 'Golden Rule'.By contrast,it is wise to acknowledge the limitation of the principle of legality and construct a measure that the social structure could set boundaries for the principle.The measure is the basis for the judiciary use of the legality principle,which is approved by ECtHR recently.
出处
《北京理工大学学报（社会科学版）》
CSSCI
2014年第6期119-124,共6页
Journal of Beijing Institute of Technology：Social Sciences Edition
基金
国家社科基金资助重大项目(11&ZD072)
