摘要
对国外开放同行评议(OPR)的期刊进行研究,分析了开放同行评议的模式;详细介绍了开放同行评议的主要价值;从透明度和开放性2个维度出发,讨论了开放同行评议的3个层次及其机制。参照7大公开要素,对开放同行评议期刊的透明度进行了等级划分,并研究了透明度等级对相对引用率RCR和社会关注度Altmetrics评分的影响。结果表明:透明度等级高的开放同行评议期刊在学术影响和社会传播力方面具有明显优势。最后,提出了一些应对开放同行评议的策略和建议,以期为科技期刊开放同行评议的开展提供参考与借鉴。
This paper investigated foreign open peerreview(OPR)journals and its mode for OPR.Then,the main value of OPR is summarized,and three different degrees of OPR and relevant mechanism were discussed from two perspectives,transparency and openness.Based on the seven key elements of openness,the transparency of OPR journals were graded,and its potential impact on relative citation rate and Altmetrics were also analyzed.The results showed that OPR journals with high level of transparency held significant advantages in academic influence and social communication.We also put forward some strategies and suggestions on implementation of OPR to provide reference for its development.
作者
王海蓉
WANG Hairong(Editorial Department of Journal of Sun Yat-sen University,510275,Guangzhou,China)
出处
《编辑学报》
北大核心
2023年第2期147-151,共5页
Acta Editologica
基金
广东省高水平科技期刊建设项目(2021B1212020009)
广东省科学技术期刊编辑学会一般项目(202038)
全国高校文科学报研究会课题“新文科建设与学术期刊高质量发展研究”(YB2021042)
关键词
开放同行评议
价值
机制
应对策略
open peer review
value
mechanism
coping strategies
